I initially agreed with you. I’d hate to see all of that communal knowledge lost.
Reading the other replies, I am not so sure. Do they deserve to continue capitalizing on other peoples knowledge? Yes and No. They did supply a service without which that collection would have had to be assembled somewhere else. But I don’t think they should be able to capitalize on it forever.
With the archive team and their efforts, I am less worried about “Wisdom of the Ancients” situation.