You are only browsing one thread in the discussion! All comments are available on the post page.

Return

Lucidlethargy ,
@Lucidlethargy@sh.itjust.works avatar

I loved this crossover, but Spock’s casting was very rough. He’s a talented actor, but he’s not Spock…

hazelnot ,

TOS is unwatchable to me so Ethan Peck has become the Spock for me lol

Terevos ,
@Terevos@lemm.ee avatar

TOS is really rough, but what about the movies? Some of those were really great. That’s the main reason Leonard Nimoy is Spock to me

hazelnot ,

Ah fair. I’ve never seen any of the Star Trek movies 😅

I started with Discovery, I liked it at the time and jumped back to TNG and went from there. I ended up skipping like half of TNG and all of Voyager though 💀

kelseybcool ,

Start with “wrath of kahn”. Thank me later.

Or don’t I’m not your dad.

Default_Defect ,
@Default_Defect@midwest.social avatar

That sounds like something my dad would say…

Stamets ,
@Stamets@startrek.website avatar

He’s not Spock…

Why?

kamenlady ,
@kamenlady@lemmy.world avatar

IMO he plays the Spock perfectly and i watched and love TOS in all its glory.

He’s not Leonard and doesn’t need to be.

These are all personal opinions anyway, but find me any one who didn’t feel it, when he went

“I’d like this ship to fly. Now!”

Benfell ,
@Benfell@hcommons.social avatar

@kamenlady @Stamets

When I think of Spock in the original series (), I find more than a few things implausible.

Would, for example, Spock really know impossible odds with multiple unknown variables to several decimal places? More seriously, in TOS, Spock never satisfactorily explained the Vulcan logic for logic. They've addressed this since, but I had realized that the attachment to life is emotional, not logical, and therefore concluded that in denying emotion, Vulcans could have no logical reason to live.

Even Leonard Nimoy's Spock addressed some of this in the movies, and they aren't quoting odds to ludicrous precision anymore, so I find the more recent iterations of Spock much more believable.

As for the acting, Ethan Peck plays a younger, less experienced Spock. Given Vulcan lifespans, this probably shouldn't make quite the difference we see. But that's how I've accounted for that difference and I've been interested in seeing the backstory.

Repelle ,

To me I feel like Ethan peck is actually very good at acting as Spock, but the writing is extremely unspock like and so it doesn’t feel right. Kirk’s writing also seems more like the mythos of Kirk remembered as by the 24th century than the actual buttoned up officer of the 23rd.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • random
  • [email protected]
  • All magazines
    •