You are only browsing one thread in the discussion! All comments are available on the post page.

Return

JohnDClay ,

Has anyone here seen this version? Does graphic novelization mean it’s graphic as in nsfw? The unedited diary does have a lot of sexual content. If it’s just a different version of the book though, that’s way overreacting.

shadearg ,
@shadearg@lemmy.world avatar

I would assume the accusation and headline would be much different if there was any kind of direct link to support a claim involving Jewry, CSAM, and public grooming.

Edit: grammar

JokeDeity ,

Jewry?

shadearg ,
@shadearg@lemmy.world avatar

The Jewish community. It’s not a vulgar or derogatory term.

JokeDeity ,

Then I’m further confused as to why it’s listed along-side child porn and child grooming?

shadearg ,
@shadearg@lemmy.world avatar

The Diary of Anne Frank was written by a Jewish girl during the Nazi occupation of the Netherlands.

There are unabridged entries in her diary in which she wrote about going through puberty and made certain specific observations about her maturing body.

OP made reference to these entries and wondered if they happened to be in this adaption:

Has anyone here seen this version? Does graphic novelization mean it’s graphic as in nsfw? The unedited diary does have a lot of sexual content.

Hence my reply.

If these were included in the adaption, there would be accusations of CSAM (graphical depictions of an underage girl exploring her body), public grooming (teaching kids that this is acceptable), and it would be aimed pointedly at Jewry (the Jewish people).

Edit: grammar

Gabu ,

I think this user was misinterpreted (as I misinterpreted it myself, originally). They’re claiming that the outcry, should legitimate issues be present, would have a different wording.

shadearg ,
@shadearg@lemmy.world avatar

They’re claiming that the outcry, should legitimate issues be present, would have a different wording.

Thank you, this is the correct interpretation.

ImplyingImplications ,

I found a pdf online. This is the most graphic part of the book. This is what scares Texans. https://lemmy.ca/pictrs/image/56edfc73-a261-4bd5-86ab-e85e2a1fdca2.jpeg

samus12345 ,
@samus12345@lemmy.world avatar

She would have been mortified to know that this was going to be published for all the world to see in the future!

teruma ,

Didn’t her father previously withhold these pages, and didn’t allow them to be published until later?

samus12345 ,
@samus12345@lemmy.world avatar

I looked it up and it looks like you’re correct, this wasn’t published until 1995. Which explains why I’d never seen it before.

teruma ,

I didn’t realize it was that much later

abbotsbury ,
@abbotsbury@lemmy.world avatar

Are there any ways to tell if a version is abridged or not?

Wahots ,
@Wahots@pawb.social avatar

She is fairly scientific in her descriptions. Doesn’t seem like a problem to me. Any health class should be covering this anyways.

teruma ,

You know they’re not in Texas…

lud ,

Does graphic novelization mean it’s graphic as in nsfw?

As far as I understand it, no.

JohnDClay ,

Okay, just as in a graphic novel, with graphics in it. Yeah an overreaction then.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • [email protected]
  • All magazines