xkcd

6mementomori , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

and I thought this had to do with light refraction lol

triclops6 ,

I mean, it kinda does?

Chrobin , (edited )

It does: Light does not follow the path of minimal distance between two points, but the path of minimal time. This is called Fermat’s principle.
Because water has a higher refraction index than air, light is slower in it and therefore takes a longer time to travel through it. Thus, it takes less time to take a longer path that spends more time in the air.
Fun fact: The underlying law of this principle is the principle of least action. This is the most basic law of nature we know of and can be used to derive all of physics.

Malfeasant ,

So… Nature is lazy?

6mementomori ,

I’d add to this that, if I’m not mistaken, it’s because light takes all possible paths and the average measured time is longer

crossover ,

The probably of the path it takes is the sum of all possible paths. Richard Feynman uses this exact swimmer in the water example during ok if his lectures.

omgarm , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

It’s been a while since I had electronics in Uni but this seems accurate.

Chadus_Maximus ,

Don’t worry, someone will eventually come and tell you that it isn’t.

meatand2veg , (edited )

I could resist the urge… But… Uh… The transcript incorrectly labels the symbol for capacitor, it’s actually the NEMA symbol for a contactor. Had to make sure I wasn’t sobbing my foot in my mouth. Capacitor symbol is extremely similar, but the right side needs to be bent like a parentheses foot it to be a capacitor like -|(-

Jorgelino328 , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

Shouldn't the path that maximizes time have its line go through literally everywhere in the globe rather than just going around it once?

GrimSheeper ,

Yes, but by then the ice cream has melted

The_Picard_Maneuver OP ,
@The_Picard_Maneuver@startrek.website avatar

We need a calculation using the speed at which ice cream melts and the max distance he could walk.

nergal ,

The path that maximizes time would just be going back and forth and not approaching the endpoint.

deliverator05 , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

I’m sorry but the symbol labelled as a wave pool is not an oscillator, it’s an AC voltage source.

AgnosticMammal ,

Isn’t AC an oscillated DC?

set_secret , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

this was our first physics lesson in year 11 in the 90s

The_Picard_Maneuver OP ,
@The_Picard_Maneuver@startrek.website avatar

Who could’ve guessed that you were training to be google maps so early?

taiyang , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

Wow, if all xkcd comics could have transcripts like this one, my uninformed ass might actually get half the jokes. :D

newIdentity ,

Check out explain xkcd then

Jakylla , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization
@Jakylla@sh.itjust.works avatar

If like me you can’t see the picutre of the post, here is the original image:

reveal!xkcd

WndyLady ,

What’s up with that? I can’t see any of the pictures hosted here.

colforge ,

I’m not positive but it might be due to the steps the Lemm.ee admin is taking to combat the CSAM uploads that have been happening and prevent the server’s administration team from being liable for potentially harmful and illegal images being hosted on their server.

taiyang , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

I feel it’s a missed opportunity to exclude the ice cream sales and drowning deaths correlation, but that’s just me. I like the maximal time route goes up, though.

TigrisMorte , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

It is simply polite to include a link to the original https://xkcd.com/2821 as per the Artist's desires.

Yes, I saw the explain, but that isn't to the actual origin.

The_Picard_Maneuver OP ,
@The_Picard_Maneuver@startrek.website avatar

Edited and added it. Thanks for the heads up

JazzAlien , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

Thanks for reminding me that I have completely brain dumped all of trigonometry

BallzofFury , in xkcd #2821: Path Minimization

Somehow he keeps on making awesome stuff, after all these years

rynzcycle , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

I love that the transcription has the correct labels for those of us who aren't sparkies.

Jakylla OP ,
@Jakylla@sh.itjust.works avatar

Not sure that this transcription is useful for person with vision disabilities unfortunately, would need some description of the symbols I think

TWeaK , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

That is a cool diode.

xuxebiko , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

This is hilarious.

Contortion , in xkcd #2818: Circuit Symbols

I'm getting the urge to listen to Metallica

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • [email protected]
  • random
  • All magazines