rbreich ,
@rbreich@masto.ai avatar

How did the Supreme Court get this far out of control? | The Coffee Klatch | June 15, 2024 https://robertreich.substack.com/p/how-did-the-supreme-court-get-this?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=mastodon

scmrak ,

@rbreich Oh, that's easy: the tyranny of the minority.

BluesHarp ,

@rbreich
Gee, what could go wrong when you have a system where politicans appoint justices? Also why were their no consequences when Merrick Garland was denied a hearing. The Senate shirked its duties.

Let's face it. Those "checks and balances" that we learned about in school don't actually exist in reality.

brettglass ,
@brettglass@newsie.social avatar

@rbreich The Major Questions Doctrine and limits on Chevron are not examples of SCOTUS getting "out of control;" they're attempts to rein in bureaucrats who have gotten out of control. The bribery, on the other hand....

Professor_Stevens ,
@Professor_Stevens@mastodon.gamedev.place avatar

@rbreich

SCOTUS got where it is because for fifty years there was only one question that decided if a president would nominate a candidate to be a justice. Each president not only demanded a "right" answer, but each also demanded an absolute certainty on that answer. After that, all other considerations, including competency to be a judge, were ignored. The ability to survive a senate committee hearing was the only other criterion.

When all your nominees are incompetent extremists...

fergusryan ,
@fergusryan@aus.social avatar

@rbreich that’s peppermint tea

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • All magazines